John Kaag on Henry David Thoreau's Walden
Which Walden Should You Read? A Guide to the Editions
with commentary by John Kaag
If you want one answer: for a first read, the Penguin Classics Walden and Civil Disobedience, which prints the 1854 first-edition text with Michael Meyer's notes and costs about what a sandwich does. For the authoritative text, the Princeton edition, edited by J. Lyndon Shanley, in the paperback with John Updike's introduction. For a second read, Jeffrey S. Cramer's Walden: A Fully Annotated Edition from Yale. John Kaag, whose Rebind series goes through the book in thirty episodes, has taught it for years and lives, as he puts it, "a stone's throw away" from the pond. His first copy was a gift, and the way he got it is the best reading advice in this guide.
Walden (1854) has one text that matters. Henry David Thoreau published it with Ticknor and Fields in Boston, it sold two thousand copies in five years, and he kept correcting his own copy afterward. The Princeton edition folds those corrections in. Everything else in print is either the 1854 text or Princeton's, and for a reader the difference is a handful of words. What differs is the help: the notes, the maps, the introductions, and the thing to avoid, which with Walden is abridgement.
The Copy Kaag Was Given
Kaag tells the story in the introduction film:
"Even as a kid, I felt the pressure as overbearing and pushing me off course, but my Latin teacher gave me Walden at the age of 14 and took me to Massachusetts to walk around the pond where Henry David Thoreau began to write the book in 1845. And at the end of this trip to Massachusetts, I told my teacher that I wanted to become not a doctor or a lawyer, but a philosopher, and live at Walden Pond and teach Thoreau."
He had already read it once, with his mother. In Episode 12, on Thoreau's chapter about reading, Kaag remembers how he learned to do it at all:
"And it wasn't until my substitute English teacher mother sat me down at the kitchen table and said, 'Okay, you've gotten your last bad mark in reading and writing, like we're going to read together. And we're going to read every single night together.' I was in eighth grade or something like that. And we did. And we read The Prince by Machiavelli, we read parts of Plato's Republic together, we read this book Walden together, Thoreau or Emerson's essays together."
So the copy to buy is one you can read with someone, or beside someone, which is what the series is for. It should also be one you'll argue with. Kaag's first reading nearly ended at the chapter on reading: "in my first read of Walden, I really almost put down the book because of this section. I thought, 'Man, you are so stuck up.'" He kept going. The editions below give you the notes to keep going too.
Penguin Classics, Walden and Civil Disobedience
The Penguin prints the first-edition text of Walden and the 1866 text of "Civil Disobedience," with notes by Michael Meyer and a 2017 introduction by Kristen Case. It is cheap, correct, and has the one essay you'll want beside the book. For a first read along with the series it's the obvious copy. Its only shortcoming is that the notes are light, which is also why it's easy to read.
Princeton, The Writings of Henry D. Thoreau
Shanley's Princeton text (1971) is the scholarly edition, built from the 1854 printing and Thoreau's own corrections and manuscripts. The paperback (2004, reissued 2016) carries Updike's introduction and nothing else: no notes, a clean page. It is the text every other edition measures itself against, and the one to own if you want Walden as a book rather than as a textbook. The Library of America volume, edited by Robert F. Sayre, collects it with A Week on the Concord and Merrimack Rivers, The Maine Woods, and Cape Cod for a reader who wants all of Thoreau's books in one place.
Yale, Walden: A Fully Annotated Edition, Edited by Jeffrey S. Cramer
Cramer, the curator of collections at the Thoreau Institute, annotated the whole book in a column beside the text: the sources Thoreau was reading, the puns, the Concord facts, the cross-references to his journal. There are more than four hundred notes on the first chapter alone. The text is the 1854 edition corrected from Thoreau's manuscripts and his marked copy. It is the edition for the second read, and the one Kaag's episodes most resemble. He spends much of the series doing what Cramer's margins do: telling you what Thoreau read, where he walked, and who lived in the woods before him. The layout is cramped and the index is poor. Buy it anyway.
Norton Critical Edition, Edited by William Rossi
The Norton (third edition, 2008) is Walden, Civil Disobedience, and Other Writings: the book, the essay, "Slavery in Massachusetts," "Walking," and "Wild Apples," all annotated, with journal excerpts from the Walden years, contemporary reviews, and eighteen critical essays. It's the edition for the arguments, and for the essays Kaag keeps reaching for in the series. The Oxford World's Classics, edited by Stephen Fender, is the alternative paperback with notes, two maps of Concord, and an appendix identifying every plant and animal Thoreau names.
A Note on What to Avoid
Abridgements. Walden is the book that gets condensed, because it is long and digressive and people want the famous sentences. Shambhala's Walden: Selections and the Condensed Classics version are both for sale, and every few years someone proposes a "modernized" Walden with the archaisms updated. None of them is the book Kaag teaches. His argument across thirty episodes is that the digressions are the point: the bean field, the ice cutters, the ledger of what the house cost. Also avoid any edition without "Civil Disobedience" if you can help it, since the series ends up there.
Reading It with Kaag
The series goes chapter by chapter, with Andrew Wessels hosting and the text read aloud between Kaag's commentary, and it does for the book what Kaag's mother did for him at the kitchen table. Start with the free introduction film. Then read Seventeen Miles from Boston, the essay that opens the series, and listen to Episode 1, Why Walden, Why Now, whose first five minutes are free. The Penguin to read. Cramer to reread. And if someone gave you your copy, keep that one.