Featuring commentary from Sadie Stein and Garth Greenwell

In chapter 59 of Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice (1813), Mr. Bennet calls Elizabeth Bennet into his library, hears her out about Darcy, and tells her: "I could not have parted with you, my Lizzy, to anyone less worthy." Sadie Stein, in her Rebind commentary on Pride and Prejudice, ranks this scene above either of Darcy's proposals:

"But the part that really makes me cry is when Elizabeth goes in to talk to her father, which, for my money, is the most moving scene in the entire novel."

In Book Two of Henry James's The Golden Bowl (1904), Adam Verver proposes to Charlotte Stant at Brighton and is accepted, and his eyes fill. He isn't thinking about Charlotte but about his daughter Maggie Verver and what he believes she has arranged for him, "what my child does for me." Garth Greenwell, in his Rebind commentary on The Golden Bowl, reads the moment without sentiment: "This man being accepted by one woman cries for another. Being accepted by the woman who will become his wife, he cries instead, thinking about his daughter. A red flag."

These are two novels in which a father's love is the formative fact of the heroine's life, and both commentators say so. Where they differ is on what that love does to the daughter, and on who finally has to end it. In Austen the father gives his daughter up himself, in half a sentence, as a gift. In James the father can't, so the daughter has to do it for both of them, and the whole plot is the cost of the delay.

Get the rest of this essay, and the whole library.

Membership

$79 a year

The rest of this essay, every episode of Sadie Stein on Pride and Prejudice, and every audio series, film and essay on the site.

“Everyone wants to be a Lizzie Bennet when they’re young.”

Sadie Stein

7-day money-back guarantee. Not ready? Join free. · Already a member? Sign in.

Read Deeper

No Voltaire: Joyce's Priest, Voltaire's Pangloss, and Two Ways of Not Asking


Philip Kitcher calls the Jesuit who blesses a barge of turf a second Pangloss; Salman Rushdie's Voltaire fought Jesuits all his life. One drowned ship each.

Go deeper →

O, I So Want to Be a Mother: The Man Who Gives Birth in Joyce and Shelley


Both novels put a man in labor. Philip Kitcher's Joyce makes him the book's tenderest wish; Charlotte Gordon's Shelley makes him its original sin.

Go deeper →

Paid In


Paul Guyer's Kant lets you hire a man if you pay him fairly. Garth Greenwell's Adam Verver pays the Prince perfectly and still does him a profound wrong.

Go deeper →

Nature Gives the Rule


John Kaag's Thoreau lifts Kant's definition of genius and gives it to a Concord woodchopper. Paul Guyer's Kant has one condition Thoreau refuses: be understood.

Go deeper →

Prison and Cemetery


Margaret Atwood watches a revolution devour its makers in real time. Megan Marshall watches one win, settle, and build a prison and a graveyard first.

Go deeper →

The Scarlet D


Boston sewed Hester's A in cloth; New York pinned Ellen's D in whispers. Marshall and Gay show which mark a woman can work, and it isn't the polite one.

Go deeper →

Who Is Maggie Verver, and Why Does Everyone Underestimate Her?


Garth Greenwell reads Maggie Verver as James's great deception: taken for an innocent, she outthinks everyone and wins by choosing the scapegoat's part.

Go deeper →

The Price of Knowing: James, Wharton, and the Women Who See Everything


Maggie Verver and May Welland are the real intelligences of their novels. Greenwell and Gay part on what each does with knowledge: reconstruction or control.

Go deeper →

Why Darcy Falls for Elizabeth in Spite of Himself


Darcy falls for Elizabeth because she alone does not perform for him, Stein argues — her wit is character, not strategy, and he falls in spite of himself.

Go deeper →

Was Charlotte Lucas Right to Marry Mr. Collins?


Stein reads Charlotte Lucas's marriage as clear-eyed and defensible: in Austen's marriage market, Elizabeth's freedom to refuse was the exception, not the rule.

Go deeper →

The Optimist's Trap: Voltaire and Marcus Aurelius Against Positive Thinking


Voltaire and Marcus Aurelius attack the same enemy: the optimism that turns your suffering into proof of your own inadequacy.

Go deeper →

Marriage, Money, and the Village Religion of Pride and Prejudice


Stein argues the romance sits on hard economics: a village credo of marriage, too few men, and a good match as the difference between security and ruin.

Go deeper →

Membership

Read the greatest books
with the people who know them best.

A library like this exists only if readers decide it should: a place where the greatest books ever written are explored, argued with, and kept alive. The people who join now make it possible. Your membership funds the next books, the next guides, the next conversations.

$79 for the year.

  • Every audio series, every film, every essay, and every book we add
  • Cancel any time, with a 7-day money-back guarantee
$79 / year
  • Every episode of every audio series
  • All films and all essays
  • Each new book the day it’s published
  • Cancel any time
Become a member

Not ready? Join free for the introductions, essays and Listen In clips.