Featuring commentary from Roxane Gay and Megan Marshall

In the fifth chapter of Edith Wharton's The Age of Innocence (1920), somebody says the word "divorce" at the Archers' table, and Wharton records the effect: "The word had fallen like a bombshell in the pure and tranquil atmosphere of the Archer dining-room." Newland Archer changes the subject. A few chapters later the Lovell Mingotts send out cards for a formal dinner to meet the Countess Olenska, and one by one the regrets come back. Nobody says why, and nobody has to.

In the second chapter of Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter (1850), the gossips of Boston stand at the foot of the scaffold and review the sentence. One says it should have been death. A young wife, holding a child by the hand, answers more softly: "let her cover the mark as she will, the pang of it will be always in her heart." Two communities, two marked women, and only one of them has been handed a needle.

Roxane Gay, in her Rebind commentary on The Age of Innocence, supplies the connection herself, in passing: "it's clear that Olenska is about to be painted with a scarlet D." Megan Marshall, in her Rebind commentary on The Scarlet Letter, never mentions Wharton, and Gay never mentions Hawthorne. But read side by side, the two commentaries make a case neither sets out to make. The visible, legislated cruelty of the theocracy leaves the marked woman more room than the invisible, deniable cruelty of old New York, and the reason is the difference between a mark you can see and one nobody will admit to giving.

Get the rest of this essay, and the whole library.

Membership

$79 a year

The rest of this essay, every episode of Roxane Gay on The Age of Innocence, and every audio series, film and essay on the site.

“What they will judge in others and condemn in others, they will absolutely allow for themselves.”

Roxane Gay

7-day money-back guarantee. Not ready? Join free. · Already a member? Sign in.

Read Deeper

No Voltaire: Joyce's Priest, Voltaire's Pangloss, and Two Ways of Not Asking


Philip Kitcher calls the Jesuit who blesses a barge of turf a second Pangloss; Salman Rushdie's Voltaire fought Jesuits all his life. One drowned ship each.

Go deeper →

O, I So Want to Be a Mother: The Man Who Gives Birth in Joyce and Shelley


Both novels put a man in labor. Philip Kitcher's Joyce makes him the book's tenderest wish; Charlotte Gordon's Shelley makes him its original sin.

Go deeper →

Nature Gives the Rule


John Kaag's Thoreau lifts Kant's definition of genius and gives it to a Concord woodchopper. Paul Guyer's Kant has one condition Thoreau refuses: be understood.

Go deeper →

Paid In


Paul Guyer's Kant lets you hire a man if you pay him fairly. Garth Greenwell's Adam Verver pays the Prince perfectly and still does him a profound wrong.

Go deeper →

Prison and Cemetery


Margaret Atwood watches a revolution devour its makers in real time. Megan Marshall watches one win, settle, and build a prison and a graveyard first.

Go deeper →

I Couldn't Have Given You Up to Anyone Less


Sadie Stein weeps at Mr. Bennet's half-sentence goodbye. Garth Greenwell reads a whole novel about a father who can't say it, so the daughter must.

Go deeper →

The Cage, Not the Romance: Roxane Gay on The Age of Innocence


Gay argues The Age of Innocence is about the cage, not the romance: a status system everyone obeys because freedom costs more than anyone will pay.

Go deeper →

The Price of Knowing: James, Wharton, and the Women Who See Everything


Maggie Verver and May Welland are the real intelligences of their novels. Greenwell and Gay part on what each does with knowledge: reconstruction or control.

Go deeper →

The Optimist's Trap: Voltaire and Marcus Aurelius Against Positive Thinking


Voltaire and Marcus Aurelius attack the same enemy: the optimism that turns your suffering into proof of your own inadequacy.

Go deeper →

Saying Yes to the Nick of Time


Thoreau's deliberate living and Nietzsche's amor fati are two disciplines with one target, Kaag and Martin show: the habit of living everywhere but now.

Go deeper →

The Knitting and the Eagle: Nietzsche, Dickens, and the Morality of Vengeance


Madame Defarge's knitting is ressentiment made visible, Atwood and Martin show — legitimate rage metastasized into a register that cannot stop expanding.

Go deeper →

Two Kinds of Nonconformity


Hester breaks the world's law in her mind; Thoreau breaks it with his feet. Marshall and Kaag on what deciding your own law actually costs.

Go deeper →

Membership

Read the greatest books
with the people who know them best.

A library like this exists only if readers decide it should: a place where the greatest books ever written are explored, argued with, and kept alive. The people who join now make it possible. Your membership funds the next books, the next guides, the next conversations.

$79 for the year.

  • Every audio series, every film, every essay, and every book we add
  • Cancel any time, with a 7-day money-back guarantee
$79 / year
  • Every episode of every audio series
  • All films and all essays
  • Each new book the day it’s published
  • Cancel any time
Become a member

Not ready? Join free for the introductions, essays and Listen In clips.