Featuring commentary from Margaret Atwood and Megan Marshall

The first chapter of The Scarlet Letter (1850) is two pages long, and it contains one of the driest sentences in American fiction. "The founders of a new colony," Nathaniel Hawthorne writes, "whatever Utopia of human virtue and happiness they might originally project, have invariably recognized it among their earliest practical necessities to allot a portion of the virgin soil as a cemetery, and another portion as the site of a prison." Megan Marshall, in her Rebind commentary on The Scarlet Letter, keeps returning to it:

"Any community, Hawthorne tells us, that seems to be the first thing they do is set up a graveyard and a prison, you know. Much utopia is this going to be."

Then there is the date. Hawthorne set his novel in the 1640s, the decade in which the Puritans in England cut off a king's head, and he opened it with a preface in which he jokes about his own firing from the Salem Custom-House as a decapitation. "So decapitation and decapitation," Marshall says. "He's playing with serious stuff, let's put it that way. Yeah, he's playing with fire."

Margaret Atwood, in her Rebind commentary on A Tale of Two Cities (1859), chose Charles Dickens for a related reason. She thinks the present is a revolution's first year, and what frightens her is the sequel. Neither commentator mentions the other's book, and Marshall never says the words Terror or Thermidor. But read together, the two commentaries divide the subject between them: Dickens shows the revolution that eats itself, and Hawthorne shows the one that won.

Get the rest of this essay, and the whole library.

Membership

$79 a year

The rest of this essay, every episode of Margaret Atwood on A Tale of Two Cities, and every audio series, film and essay on the site.

“The real hero of A Tale of Two Cities is Sydney Carton — the desolate, drunken reprobate.”

Margaret Atwood

7-day money-back guarantee. Not ready? Join free. · Already a member? Sign in.

Read Deeper

No Voltaire: Joyce's Priest, Voltaire's Pangloss, and Two Ways of Not Asking


Philip Kitcher calls the Jesuit who blesses a barge of turf a second Pangloss; Salman Rushdie's Voltaire fought Jesuits all his life. One drowned ship each.

Go deeper →

O, I So Want to Be a Mother: The Man Who Gives Birth in Joyce and Shelley


Both novels put a man in labor. Philip Kitcher's Joyce makes him the book's tenderest wish; Charlotte Gordon's Shelley makes him its original sin.

Go deeper →

Paid In


Paul Guyer's Kant lets you hire a man if you pay him fairly. Garth Greenwell's Adam Verver pays the Prince perfectly and still does him a profound wrong.

Go deeper →

Nature Gives the Rule


John Kaag's Thoreau lifts Kant's definition of genius and gives it to a Concord woodchopper. Paul Guyer's Kant has one condition Thoreau refuses: be understood.

Go deeper →

I Couldn't Have Given You Up to Anyone Less


Sadie Stein weeps at Mr. Bennet's half-sentence goodbye. Garth Greenwell reads a whole novel about a father who can't say it, so the daughter must.

Go deeper →

The Scarlet D


Boston sewed Hester's A in cloth; New York pinned Ellen's D in whispers. Marshall and Gay show which mark a woman can work, and it isn't the polite one.

Go deeper →

The Women of A Tale of Two Cities: Lucie, Pross, and Defarge


Atwood on Dickens's three women: only the childless can fight, and the villain Dickens loved most — Madame Defarge — is the novel's real heroine.

Go deeper →

Who Is Sydney Carton? Margaret Atwood on the Real Hero of A Tale of Two Cities


Margaret Atwood reads Sydney Carton, not Charles Darnay, as the real hero of A Tale of Two Cities: a drunk, a double, and the man Dickens actually wrote.

Go deeper →

The Price of Knowing: James, Wharton, and the Women Who See Everything


Maggie Verver and May Welland are the real intelligences of their novels. Greenwell and Gay part on what each does with knowledge: reconstruction or control.

Go deeper →

The Optimist's Trap: Voltaire and Marcus Aurelius Against Positive Thinking


Voltaire and Marcus Aurelius attack the same enemy: the optimism that turns your suffering into proof of your own inadequacy.

Go deeper →

The Knitting and the Eagle: Nietzsche, Dickens, and the Morality of Vengeance


Madame Defarge's knitting is ressentiment made visible, Atwood and Martin show — legitimate rage metastasized into a register that cannot stop expanding.

Go deeper →

Saying Yes to the Nick of Time


Thoreau's deliberate living and Nietzsche's amor fati are two disciplines with one target, Kaag and Martin show: the habit of living everywhere but now.

Go deeper →

Membership

Read the greatest books
with the people who know them best.

A library like this exists only if readers decide it should: a place where the greatest books ever written are explored, argued with, and kept alive. The people who join now make it possible. Your membership funds the next books, the next guides, the next conversations.

$79 for the year.

  • Every audio series, every film, every essay, and every book we add
  • Cancel any time, with a 7-day money-back guarantee
$79 / year
  • Every episode of every audio series
  • All films and all essays
  • Each new book the day it’s published
  • Cancel any time
Become a member

Not ready? Join free for the introductions, essays and Listen In clips.