Subscribe
Megan Marshall on Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter

Episode 7

I Have No Heavenly Father

Featuring Megan Marshall

Audio episode · 15 min

Megan Marshall on The Scarlet Letter

Pearl asks the question every parent fumbles, and answers the catechism with the wildest line in the book. Marshall traces that answer to a real New England nursery: the Peabody family lore Hawthorne knew firsthand, and the century's live argument over whether a child is born sinful or born innocent.

This post is for paying subscribers only

Subscribe to continue reading

Read Deeper

What Does the A on Hester's Chest Actually Mean?

The A never holds still: adulteress at the scaffold, able and armor at the cottage, awe by the end — Marshall tracks a symbol its makers couldn't control.

Go deeper →

Two Kinds of Nonconformity

Hester breaks the world's law in her mind; Thoreau breaks it with his feet. Marshall and Kaag on what deciding your own law actually costs.

Go deeper →

Is The Scarlet Letter a Feminist Novel?

Yes, Marshall argues: Hawthorne put Margaret Fuller's feminist theory in Hester's mind, atoning for a family history of silencing women — blind spots and all.

Go deeper →

Did Hester Prynne Sin Alone?

No — and Marshall reads Hawthorne's suspended question as widening the guilt past Dimmesdale and Chillingworth to the whole community standing in judgment.

Go deeper →

Read with the Best

A literary publication for the self-taught reader. Where to start, which translation, why it matters — with editors who'll actually take a side.