Who Is Sydney Carton? Margaret Atwood on the Real Hero of A Tale of Two Cities

with commentary by Margaret Atwood

A Tale of Two Cities has an official hero and a real one. The official hero is Charles Darnay: reformed French aristocrat, devoted husband, man of unimpeachable principle. The real one is Sydney Carton: drunken, self-loathing, brilliant, and in love with a woman he will never have. Charles Dickens knew which one he was actually writing. So did Ronald Colman, who took the lead in the 1935 film and made it about Carton from the first scene.

“The real hero of A Tale of Two Cities is Sydney Carton,” Margaret Atwood says in her Rebind commentary on the novel. “We feel for him. We know he’s not a hero. We understand him better than we understand Charles Darnay, who comes across as somewhat wooden.” The misreading of Carton, as a simple sacrificial figure, a sentimental Victorian redemption story, misses what Dickens was building from the novel’s first page.

Carton and Darnay, the double

Carton and Darnay are introduced as virtual twins. They share a face: close enough that at Darnay’s first London treason trial, Carton’s resemblance gets Darnay acquitted by creating reasonable doubt about the prosecution’s identification. But the resemblance is not just physical. Atwood reads them as aspects of the same person, not mirror opposites but the same nature divided against itself.

Atwood places this in the tradition that Robert Louis Stevenson would articulate explicitly in Jekyll and Hyde in 1886, twenty-seven years after A Tale of Two Cities: “Jekyll and Hyde — Jekyll doesn’t have a clue. He thinks that he and Hyde are entirely different people. He has not recognized that Hyde is him. And Carton, at the end, recognizes that he and Darnay are aspects of the same person. That’s what the look-alike thing is about.” Darnay is who Carton might have been. Carton is what Darnay carries in shadow.

Why Carton drinks

Carton reveals himself in Book Two, Chapter Thirteen: sitting beside Lucie Manette, confessing his feelings, in a scene Atwood reads as the Chekhov pistol of the entire novel. He tells her he is a wasted man. He tells her there is nothing in him worth having. He tells her he would die for her and for anyone she loves.

Atwood reads Carton’s self-destruction as addiction rather than moral failure. “He’s an addict,” she says in her Rebind commentary. “And Dickens is describing that behavior pretty accurately: I’m going to be better today. I won’t do this bad thing today. And then you do it. And Carton knows that about himself because he’s been living that pattern for years, and he doesn’t think he has it within himself to renounce it.” The promise he makes Lucie is not a sentimental gesture. It is the only thing he believes himself capable of: one unrepeatable act, done well.

The devil has all the best lines, as Atwood puts it. “If there’s no fall in the Garden of Eden, there’s no redemption. It’s called the fortunate fall.” Darnay without Carton is a novel with no shadow. It would be unreadable.

Stryver's jackal

Mr. Stryver is the barrister Carton works for, and Dickens gives their arrangement a chapter of its own, Book Two, chapter five, titled “The Jackal.” Stryver is the lion, “fast shouldering his way to a large and lucrative practice.” Carton is the jackal who sits up until three in the morning with wet towels folded on his head, boiling down the papers Stryver will stand up with in court the next day and take the credit for, as he did at Darnay’s treason trial. Stryver calls him “Memory,” and means it as a job title. When Stryver decides to propose to Lucie, it takes Mr. Lorry to talk him out of it. Later, hearing of a French aristocrat who renounced his title and estate, he calls the man a fellow infected by “the most pestilent and blasphemous code of devilry that ever was known,” to Darnay’s face, without knowing who he is talking to.

Atwood is blunt about why Stryver is in the book. “He’s there to give Sydney Carton a job,” she says, “because he’s pretty unemployable otherwise.” It is not kindness. “He’s not doing it because he’s being nice to Sydney Carton. He’s doing it because he’s using Sydney Carton.” Asked whether the two are friends, she doesn’t pause: “It’s instrumental. They’re not friends. Stryver is just such a blimp.” The humiliation is part of the arrangement. Stryver is “always dressing him down and telling him how worthless he is,” and the message underneath is plain: “Because nobody else is going to hire you. You got to stick with me.” Her verdict is “a really disgusting relationship.” It is also the addiction reading from the employer’s side. A man who despises himself and can’t stop drinking needs work that asks nothing of him beyond the night’s labor and the next day’s silence, and Stryver is the one employer an addict can keep.

Is Carton's death a redemption?

Book Three, Chapter Thirteen. Carton enters Darnay’s cell in the Conciergerie, the prison where the condemned await the guillotine. Within minutes the two men have exchanged clothes, names, and fates. Darnay is drugged and carried out as Carton. Carton remains as Darnay. He will go to the guillotine in Darnay’s place.

The substitution works as a plot device because of the physical resemblance. It works as a moral argument because Atwood reads it as blood sacrifice: the ancient logic of the substitute who dies so the number can remain complete. “We’re in the realm of ancient Greek tragedy,” she says. “We’re in the Oresteia. The bloodline demands a death. The gods needed something in exchange.”

It also works biographically. Before Dickens wrote the novel, he co-wrote and performed in a play called The Frozen Deep, in which he played the dark, brooding man who sacrifices himself so the woman he loves can be happy with another. “Charles Dickens played that role,” Atwood says. “He was an amateur actor.” The actor who made audiences weep became the writer who made readers weep. Carton’s sacrifice was rehearsed on stage before it was written on the page.

The Last Moments

Dickens gives Carton’s final thoughts as imagined prophecy rather than witnessed speech. Carton sees the new oppressors falling by the same instrument that killed the old ones, which Atwood reads as historical fact. “He was writing in 1859,” she says. “So by that time they’d had two other revolutionary periods and several restorations of the monarchy.” The Thermidorian reaction happened. Dickens also gives Carton a vision of the Manette family producing a boy named after him, who produces another boy with the same name. Atwood traces this to Macbeth: Banquo’s line giving rise to kings. And then to Hamlet: “I hear him tell the child my story. ‘Absent thee from felicity awhile, to tell my story.’ Very important to Dickens. Somebody tells the story.”

The famous last sentence works, Atwood observes, because of how it is written, not just what it says: “It is a far, far better thing that I do, than I have ever done; it is a far, far better rest that I go to than I have ever known.” “He could have just said, I’ve done a good thing, and it’s better than what I’d done before. But that would not have had the same effect.” The art is inseparable from the meaning. This is what Atwood means when she says the devil has all the best lines: not that Carton is evil but that the fallen character, the shadow figure, always carries the novel’s most alive prose.

Carton on screen in 2026

The newest adaptation is a four-part A Tale of Two Cities created and written by Daniel West and directed by Richard R. Clark, with Kit Harington as Sydney Carton, François Civil as Charles Darnay, Mirren Mack as Lucie Manette, Sharon Duncan-Brewster as Hester Pross and Guillaume Gallienne as Dr. Manette. It premiered on MGM+ in the United States on September 6, 2026, and ran in weekly episodes through October 4. A BBC One date for the UK has not been announced. The reviews were mixed.

The casting tells an old story. Ronald Colman took the lead in 1935 and the film became Carton’s. Dirk Bogarde did the same in 1958, and every version since has followed, whatever order the names come in on the poster. Darnay gets the wife and the acquittals; Carton gets the actor. A production that hands its best-known face to the drunk at the back of the courtroom has read the novel the way Atwood reads it: the official hero is the man the plot needs, and the real one is the man the book is about.

Further Reading

Membership

Read the greatest books
with the people who know them best.

A library like this exists only if readers decide it should: a place where the greatest books ever written are explored, argued with, and kept alive. The people who join now make it possible. Your membership funds the next books, the next guides, the next conversations.

$79 for the year.

  • Every audio series, every film, every essay, and every book we add
  • Cancel any time, with a 7-day money-back guarantee
$79 / year
  • Every episode of every audio series
  • All films and all essays
  • Each new book the day it’s published
  • Cancel any time
Become a member

Not ready? Join free for the introductions, essays and Listen In clips.