The Women of A Tale of Two Cities: Lucie, Pross, and Defarge

with commentary by Margaret Atwood

Charles Dickens gave A Tale of Two Cities three significant female characters. Lucie Manette: golden-haired, empathetic, the Victorian ideal made flesh. Miss Pross: plain, fierce, single, fiercely devoted to the family she serves. Madame Defarge: stout, watchful, knitting a death register in a wine-shop in Saint Antoine. None of them are accidents. Margaret Atwood’s Rebind commentary on the novel is, among other things, a sustained account of exactly how deliberately Dickens designed each woman, and what the design reveals about the ideology he was both selling and quietly subverting.

Lucie Manette: The Angel in the House

In 1854, the poet Coventry Patmore published “The Angel in the House,” the definitive statement of Victorian femininity, which is to say pure, self-abnegating, the moral center of the household, incapable of independent action. Three years later, Dickens was writing out the contours of Lucie Manette: eighteen years old, golden-haired, fainting on cue.

Atwood’s argument is that Lucie is not simply a type but rather a memory of a specific person: Dickens’s dead sister-in-law Mary Hogarth, who died at seventeen in his arms in 1837 and whose ring he wore for the rest of his life. “She was the unobtainable ideal, who then died,” Atwood says in her Rebind commentary. “So she remained a vision of perfection: unobtainable and also dead.” By the time he was writing the novel, Dickens was also falling for eighteen-year-old actress Ellen Ternan, and had just performed in a play called The Frozen Deep, in which a man sacrifices himself so the woman he loves can be happy with someone else. The triangle was on his mind. His life had embodied the archetype.

The ideology behind Lucie goes back further than Patmore. Atwood traces the maternal ideal to Jean-Jacques Rousseau’s 1762 Emile, which argued that aristocratic wet-nursing was a civilizational failure and that mothers should breastfeed their own children. Rousseau invented maternal breastfeeding as moral ideology. The fashionable women of Monseigneur’s court, who have farmed their children out to wet nurses and gone to parties, are what Dickens is contrasting with Lucie. “Not one fashionable court woman is a real mother,” Atwood reads. “The leprosy of unreality. That’s what this is.”

Lucie’s credential, in Victorian terms, is that she has not one but two children: a living daughter and an angelic dead one. The dead child matters enormously. “There were a lot of angelic dead children in Victorian life,” Atwood observes. For a Victorian reader, a mother who has suffered the death of a child has passed the ultimate test of maternal devotion.

But Atwood refuses the reading of Lucie as merely passive. In the novel’s final third, Lucie has come to Paris during the Terror, stood daily in a woodcutter’s courtyard in case her husband Charles Darnay can see her from his cell, and held a domestic space together under revolutionary surveillance. “She’s not a weak person,” Atwood says. “She’s actually, in her own way, been pretty strong throughout this ordeal.” The Angel in the House was not a decoration. Florence Nightingale used exactly the role of the ministering angel (impeccable morality, upper-class) to make military bureaucrats bend to her will.

Miss Pross: The Woman Who Can Fight

Miss Pross, Lucie’s plain, fierce, devoted companion, exists, in Atwood’s reading, for one structural purpose: she is the only character in the novel who can physically confront Madame Defarge. And she can do this for one reason: she has no children.

“Lucie Manette is the prototypical young Victorian ideal woman in that she’s very empathetic, very kind, very nurturing, very fainty, very clingy,” Atwood says. “And she wouldn’t have lasted one second against Madame Defarge. You need a Miss Pross to go up against Madame Defarge.” The Angel in the House cannot be a protagonist. She holds the center together but cannot throw a punch. Pross can. And the reason is the same reason that Defarge can: neither of them are mothers.

The fight between Pross and Defarge in Chapter Fourteen of Book Three is engineered precisely. Two women alone in a Paris room. Neither speaks the other’s language. A pistol. Defarge makes for the door; Pross seizes her; they struggle. The gun goes off by accident. Defarge dies; Pross goes permanently deaf.

“The gun has to go off by accident,” Atwood says. “Miss Pross cannot be a murderer. She cannot be an intentional murderer. Bang. Oh, what have I done?” Unlike Madame Defarge, who would have known exactly what she had done.

Read the rest with a free account

Check your inbox for a sign-in link.

Something went wrong. Please try again.

Or get everything

Membership

$79 a year

The rest of this essay, every episode of Margaret Atwood on A Tale of Two Cities, and every audio series, film and essay on the site.

“The real hero of A Tale of Two Cities is Sydney Carton — the desolate, drunken reprobate.”

Margaret Atwood

7-day money-back guarantee.

Further Reading

Membership

Read the greatest books
with the people who know them best.

A library like this exists only if readers decide it should: a place where the greatest books ever written are explored, argued with, and kept alive. The people who join now make it possible. Your membership funds the next books, the next guides, the next conversations.

$79 for the year.

  • Every audio series, every film, every essay, and every book we add
  • Cancel any time, with a 7-day money-back guarantee
$79 / year
  • Every episode of every audio series
  • All films and all essays
  • Each new book the day it’s published
  • Cancel any time
Become a member

Not ready? Join free for the introductions, essays and Listen In clips.